Cadillac, Lincoln seek to regain ground in luxury market

Rebecca Cook / Reuters

Cadillac is betting that it can regain its once-lofty standing with the launch of a series of new products that includes the big XTS sedan that made its debut earlier this month at the annual Los Angeles auto show.

By Paul A. Eisenstein

Once known as the “standard of the world,” Cadillac has been anything but a benchmark for carmakers in recent years as imported brands such as Lexus, BMW and Mercedes-Benz have dominated the U.S. luxury market.

But now Cadillac is fighting back, betting that it can regain its once-lofty standing with the launch of a series of new products that includes the big XTS sedan that made its debut earlier this month at the annual Los Angeles auto show.

Cadillac will follow up next year with the addition of the compact ATS, and it has more new models on the drawing board.

A few years ago it might have seemed “a stretch” for Cadillac to even imagine a comeback in the U.S., admits Don Butler, general marketing manager for the General Motors division.

In the “new (luxury) world old formulas don’t apply, so we had to start over” with the XTS, a premium luxury sedan that replaces two slow-selling Cadillac models, the STS and DTS, Butler said.

Caddy isn’t the only upscale domestic car brand that’s hoping to convince car show visitors in Los Angeles -- the nation's largest luxury car market -- that it can become relevant again.

Slide show: Images from the 2011 Los Angeles auto show

At this year’s show, Ford’s Lincoln division showed off updates to two of its own products, the big MKS sedan and MKT crossover. The two 2013 models get revised fascias and grilles, new wheels and modest improvements in performance and fuel economy. They’re also getting the updated version of the MyLincolnTouch systems designed to address recent criticism of the brand’s infotainment technology.

“This is truly marking the beginning” of Lincoln’s design renaissance, said Max Wolff, the brand’s chief designer, although he also hinted that the big news for Lincoln won’t be revealed until January when Detroit plays host to the North American International Auto Show -- generally thought to be the most important show in the auto show calendar.

There, the automaker plans to unveil a concept version of its next-generation Lincoln MKZ, the most popular sedan in its portfolio. The concept vehicle will introduce an all-new “face” for the luxury brand that will abandon Lincoln’s time-tested “waterfall grille” and move to a series of horizontal slats that are almost wing-like in appearance. The show car version will also feature an all-glass roof that will be able to open like a hard-top convertible.

The revised grille will reappear on a production version of the MKZ debuting at the New York auto show next April, although it’s not clear if the glass roof idea will be carried into production.

But the dramatic changes coming to Lincoln underscore the concerns Ford has for the Lincoln division, which has become little more than an also-ran in a market where it once vied with Cadillac for dominance.

Cadillac hasn’t stumbled quite so badly, but it has been struggling in recent years after what appeared to be a significant turnaround early in the new millennium. The maker scored big with the first generation of the compact CTS sedan, which introduced Caddy’s distinctively edgy “art and science” design theme.

In a segment of the car market where manufacturers have traditionally opted for softer designs, the “art and science” design “language” was a bold standout. But after hitting a market home run with the CTS, Cadillac failed to score with the next run of offerings, like the STS, the DTS and the XLR sports coupe.

The products simply fell short of the competition in terms of interior refinement, ride and features, analysts contend.

Cadillac won’t make those mistakes again, insists Mark Reuss, president of GM’s North American operations. The goal, he insists, “is to win in the intensely competitive luxury market, not just compete.”

Besides offering a striking exterior shape and a much more refined interior, the new XTS will introduce Cadillac’s new CUE -- an infotainment system that can be programmed using normal speech rather than requiring users to learn a complex and often confusing series of rigid commands.

These high-tech features have become a critical differentiator in the luxury market, notes Derek Kuzak, Ford’s global product development czar.

Lincoln thought it had a leg up on the competition with the MyLincolnTouch infotainment system, but, underscoring the risks of relying on high technology, the Ford luxury brand was slammed for problems with the touch-sensitive system. Indeed, influential Consumer Reports magazine lifted its sought-after “Recommended Buy” rating from several Lincoln products this year.

The carmaker hopes to win back that endorsement with the updated MyLincolnTouch, and then show that its styling and performance are also relevant with the product offensive it is kicking off in Los Angeles this month.

But both Lincoln and Cadillac won’t have an easy time of it. Even established luxury brands such as Lexus, BMW and Mercedes are ramping up their own efforts. Lexus, in particular, is expected to be especially aggressive in the months ahead, hoping to recover the momentum it lost due to product shortages caused by the earthquake and tsunami in Japan last March.

And second-tier players such as Audi, and also Nissan’s Infiniti brand, are hoping to gain ground with their own expanding line-ups.

Then there’s the Koreans, and Hyundai in particular.

It scored an unexpected coup a few years back when its first luxury offering, the Genesis sedan, was named North American Car of the Year. The even bigger and more lavish Equus has so far this year handily beaten the company’s sales expectations, and Hyundai’s own new offering at the Los Angeles show, the big Azera, will target entry-luxury buyers who might have gone for more traditional offerings like the Lexus ES350.

Based on initial reviews, Cadillac and Lincoln are gaining visibility and credibility. But whether they can win back luxury car buyers is another matter entirely.

What is your favorite luxury nameplate?

Results with 56 short comments
Total of 5,850 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

38.1%
Cadillac
2,230 votes
8.3%
Lincoln
486 votes
18.9%
BMW
1,108 votes
16.5%
Mercedes-Benz
966 votes
11.8%
Lexus
689 votes
6.3%
Other (specify in comment)
371 votes
Display Comments:
Cadillac

Never forgave my mothers husband for trashing 'my' beloved '64 Caddy

     - 8:35 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
    Cadillac

    My wife has a CTS and it has been a wonderful car. We'll replace it with another Cadillac eventually.

       - 8:51 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
      Other (specify in comment)

      Jaguar- with its new XF XJ designs Cadillac is gonna have a hard time competing with the new Jaaags.

         - 9:31 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
        Other (specify in comment)

        All cars today are what luxury was 10 years ago, no need for spending extra money for a name. Most of what they offer I don't want or need,

        • 1 vote
         - 9:34 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
        Other (specify in comment)

        Infinity

        • 1 vote
         - 9:36 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
        Cadillac

        Cadillac USED to be favorite until they removed the V8 from the STS.

        • 1 vote
         - 9:55 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
        Cadillac

        I think Cadillac is making a huge mistake replacing the DTS model. GM shooting themselves in the foot again! Guess GM will never learn...

        • 1 vote
         - 10:08 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
        Lexus

        Poor Mercedes fell off years ago.

        • 1 vote
         - 10:09 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
        Cadillac

        I just love the new Cadillacs. They are the leader of the luxury field hands down.

           - 10:12 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
          Lexus

          .."simply fell short..interior refinement, ride and features".....and quality, a $50k car should not fall apart after five years/50k miles.

          • 2 votes
           - 10:12 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
          Other (specify in comment)

          Audi all the way!!

          • 3 votes
           - 10:52 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
          Other (specify in comment)

          Personally, I have a thing for Infiniti. I especially like the G-Coupe, but I also like the M sedan.

          • 1 vote
           - 10:54 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
          Other (specify in comment)

          Tesla baby! Then Chevy Volt. Then Cadillac. Used nameplates: Mercedes.

             - 10:59 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
            Cadillac

            The CTS-V is plainly the finest machine in it's class and trumps any BMW.

            • 1 vote
             - 11:14 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
            Other (specify in comment)

            Acura

            • 1 vote
             - 11:24 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
            Other (specify in comment)

            Rolls-Royce and Bentley are tied for me then followed by Mercedes and Jag. The American manufactures don't seem to understand luxury

               - 11:35 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
              BMW

              If they want to regain ground, produce a dependable product. Not presently known for quality but are known for not holding value

              • 1 vote
               - 11:45 am EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
              Other (specify in comment)

              Although I support American made brands, Audi has some great cars that perform and look good.

              • 2 votes
               - 1:01 pm EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
              Other (specify in comment)

              Audi

              • 2 votes
               - DKBro
               - 1:05 pm EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
              Other (specify in comment)

              Infiniti - or nothing else

                 - 2:25 pm EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
                Other (specify in comment)

                AUDI.

                GM needs to fire the Batmobile design team and hire some grown-ups instead.

                • 1 vote
                 - 2:26 pm EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
                BMW

                Want car that demands to be driven NOT one that caresses you to sleep through boredom. Stereotype still exists of cars fit for old guys.

                   - 2:32 pm EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
                  Other (specify in comment)

                  Audi. The best car in the sgment for style, luxury and performance.

                  • 1 vote
                   - 3:12 pm EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
                  Other (specify in comment)

                  Infiniti...terrific cars, IMHO...

                  • 1 vote
                   - 3:22 pm EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011
                  Mercedes-Benz

                  My problem with Caddy, Lincoln, Lexus, and Infiniti is so many of their models share important components with much less expensive cars.

                     - 3:39 pm EST on Wed Nov 23, 2011

                    Discuss this post

                    Jump to discussion page: 1 2

                    The day I buy a Cadillac, uggh.

                    • 3 votes
                    Reply#1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 8:47 AM EST

                    Agreed. It might help if they weren't so butt-ugly, which they always have been.

                    • 4 votes
                    #1.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 1:26 PM EST

                    Cadillac is coming back in terms of design, the 70's - late 2000's weren't a good look.

                    But when it comes down to it, I think the line between American and foreign companies is pretty well blurred beyond recognition now. My Honda was built in Ohio. BMW and Mercedes both have US Plants. Most relevant automotive manufacturers have plants in the United States, whereas a growing number of GM plants are in Canada and Mexico.

                    I don't particularly care where the company itself is located, but it means something that the cars I buy were built in the U.S. by Americans. In a global economy where we manufacture very little these days, we must support however possible.

                    • 1 vote
                    #1.2 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 3:46 PM EST

                    The new XTS is a front wheel drive vehicle while the competition in the luxury market features rear wheel drive vehicles. Front wheel drive is generally considered a mass produced cookie cutter setup and plopping a luxury body onto a front wheel drive chassis will be a turn off for many.

                    The other luxury car makers are aware of this fact; hence they employ rear wheel drive which is consistent with the perception of luxury.

                    • 3 votes
                    #1.3 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 4:38 PM EST

                    Here is a stretch: "Once known as the ‘standard of the world"

                    What world was that? Bum fu.k Egypt? Cadillac was never a standard but for ugliness, poor quality as well as outdated technology. This brand was never relevant to anything positive and never will be a contender in the Luxury Car Market. And Herr Eisenstein, any Audi is better built than a Cadillac and calling them a second tier car manufacturer in the Luxury Class is a joke.

                    Ah well, I stick with my trusted Benz.

                    • 1 vote
                    #1.4 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 7:57 PM EST

                    GDVegas: Might pay a little more attention to American automotive history, Cadillac WAS the standard leading into the 70's. Past that, I'd argue that only a handful of revolutionary or inspired vehicles came out of GM from 1970 - 2005.

                      #1.5 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 9:28 PM EST
                      Reply

                      This article is so wrong. The US brand best positioned to come out on top of the domestic luxury market is ... Chrysler! For decades Cadillac has been nothing more than a decked-out Chevy. Lincoln will remain lost unless they can find their way back to the refined luxury of '61-'69 (the Pontiac grills certainly don't help!). Chrysler so destroyed itself in the 80's that it's name no longer carries any old-fogie baggage, and they have no older buyers to try and maintain. It's 300 was and remains on target with it's euro-ish lines, performance and luxury, and now with car people behind the scenes again they will likely be able to expand on that success.

                      • 4 votes
                      Reply#2 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 9:21 AM EST

                      I agree. Chrysler is uniquely positioned to top Caddy and Lincoln. I hope they can pull it off.

                        #2.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 9:46 AM EST

                        Chrysler is owned by Fiat, Fiat is Italian, before that they were owned by a private firm and before that owned by Mercedes I believe, so honestly should they even be considered a domestic? So the real choice is a Government owned Company that is propped up at the cost of taxpayers for Billions and Billions to show profits or Lincoln that did not require a bailout. I do agree that as long as Cadillac is under the GM, they will be considered an upscale Chevy by many as they share chassis, engines and such at times. The XTS in the pic has some good looks on the sides but Im not a big fan of the rear or fronts of Cads and a quick google search showed the XTS will be assembled in Canada which is NOT the US and as such I consider an import.

                        • 1 vote
                        #2.2 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 10:46 AM EST

                        I can't agree regarding Chrysler. Branding is everything when it comes to luxury, and Cadillac is by far the most relevant in pop culture and amongst the under 40 crowd (relevant in terms of "american" car brands). Limousines, chartered transportation, and even the Presidential fleet are all Cadillacs. Chrysler has none of that relevance and has a whopping 4 models on the market, 3 of which are the same car...the other, a minivan.

                          #2.3 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 3:54 PM EST

                          Chrylser 300 was one of the best cars I ever owned. But it had two nasty problems that no one could fix: warping brake rotors and the air conditioning system failed one component at a time. But I got 170,000 miles out of the car. If not for those stupid problems, I would still be driving it today. But the brakes and the AC were costing me a bundle (and never really got fixed), so I switched to BMW. I test drove Cadillac, Lexus, and Acura, but the driving experience made it an easy choice.

                            #2.4 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 10:09 PM EST

                            I agree. The 300c is superior to Cadillac's 'parts bin' "luxury cars".

                            German cars are a nightmare out of warranty.

                            I hope that Chrysler produces and Imperial... but also, that Lincoln really does revive itself and provide some much needed competition for the European and Japanese marques.

                              #2.5 - Thu Nov 24, 2011 9:28 PM EST

                              peteMT, you're aware that the 300C uses Mercedes mechanicals, right?

                                #2.6 - Thu Nov 24, 2011 10:11 PM EST

                                Repost response with a repost response:

                                I do, as a matter of fact. But it's just the suspension, some wiring, a few other minor things, and 5 speed automatic (which has been refined for ten years to be reliable). Yes, they used the previous generation Mercedes components, probably because Mercedes was incredibly cheap while running the show. I think the AWD system was Mercedes, or a variation, but the 2011's may have changed that.

                                The 3.6 and the new 8 speed auto, are not.

                                  #2.7 - Fri Nov 25, 2011 10:50 AM EST
                                  Reply

                                  I think Cadillac is making a huge mistake replacing the DTS model. GM shooting themselves in the foot again! Guess GM will never learn...

                                    Reply#3 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 10:15 AM EST

                                    Miss those massive land yachts, power everything. Felt like riding down the road in your living room. The other guy was right though. They do fall apart after 4-5 years.

                                    • 1 vote
                                    Reply#4 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 10:46 AM EST

                                    There can be only one. CADILLAC

                                    • 1 vote
                                    Reply#5 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 10:57 AM EST

                                    Hay, Paul A. Eisenstein, what planet do you live on? Government Motors still produces ill fitting junk, and the Cad is in the same position being built by the communist UAW, just like the Chevy.......cheap junk.

                                    GM lost, KIA is ahead of them! Rented the expensive CAD CTS or what ever the initials, looked at the instrument panel, the door alignment missed the instrument panel by a 1/2 inch. Has not changed since 1955. And the CAD is their best?


                                    • 2 votes
                                    Reply#6 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 11:10 AM EST

                                    Cadillacs have been pure junk for over thirty years now, so the chances of them bringing this company back are very slim.......

                                    • 1 vote
                                    Reply#7 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 11:15 AM EST

                                    Your out of touch

                                      #7.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 7:30 PM EST

                                      I'll agree that their cars have, for the most part, been crap for several decades. Branding wise, they are very well positioned for a comeback though. The Escalade saved them, but a 13MPG SUV will only take them so far. They need more innovative vehicles. Nothing they have at the moment is a real head turner.

                                        #7.2 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 9:36 PM EST
                                        Reply

                                        Cadillac SUV's, Jeeps, trucks, imitation family cars and they want to retake the lead in the luxury car market? I'm surprised they didn't go after the police and highway department patrol cars in the last decade.

                                          Reply#8 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 11:17 AM EST

                                          btw: Jeep is Chrysler, and now leads the domestic automotive market in quality.

                                          Regarding Cadillac, they need to thin out their model lineup and reintroduce only a handful of exciting vehicles.

                                          • 1 vote
                                          #8.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 9:39 PM EST
                                          Reply

                                          Judging from the voters comments the average person doesn't understand luxury any more than the American car companies. Luxury is not about gadgets. It's not about bigger or more. Luxury is about quality of material and finish. Luxury is about attention to detail.

                                          If a person believes that any American car can match the German top brands (Mercedes, BMW, Audi) then they simply don't understand the concept.

                                            Reply#9 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 11:43 AM EST

                                            I am a 4 time BMW owner and can tell from experience that the Europen cars are as or even more unreliable as American models. Several years ago I got so tired of spending time in the repair isles of my local BMW dealer at an average shot of $1,000 that I dumped my 540 and switched, what a lot of people thought to be a bad move, to Hyundai. I am now in my second Hyundai and have not seen the inside of a repair isle as yet. There is a certain level of luxury in reliablility besides just gadgets. Having said that, I admit that the handling and power train of the 540, when functioning well, is a dream. But, since I am not a ralley driver, I do not miss it that much. The luxury that Hyundai provides me with is more that sufficient.

                                            • 2 votes
                                            #9.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 1:52 PM EST

                                            Quality is also long term reliability, something which your so precious German brands utterly lack.

                                            I would take any domestic vehicle any day of the week for long term ownership over a Mercedes, BMW, or Audi. Repairs are frequent and terrifyingly expensive. Just do some reading on the net and see what the second and third owners of these cars have to say.

                                            No thanks, that's what I have to say.

                                            300C, hemi, AWD all the way. Bulletproof mechanicals, superb interior quality, and repairable in every town.

                                              #9.2 - Thu Nov 24, 2011 9:33 PM EST
                                              Reply

                                              Chrysler??

                                              You've got to be kidding me!!!  The tacky "Gangsta" brand with the 300??  LMAO!!!

                                              I bet you like shiny 24" chrome spinners, too....

                                              • 2 votes
                                              Reply#10 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 11:50 AM EST

                                              I didn't say I liked the Chrysler, only that it best hits its target market. Personally, I prefer a Roll Royce Phantom!

                                                #10.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 12:57 PM EST
                                                Reply

                                                i would not buy anything thats going to be made in china or owned by the unions or our goverment

                                                • 1 vote
                                                Reply#11 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 11:56 AM EST

                                                1996 Lexus LS400..157,000 miles...Effortless driving..Best dealer service..

                                                  Reply#12 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 12:13 PM EST

                                                  I don't trust the Lexus anymore. Have you read the recalls????

                                                    #12.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 7:28 PM EST
                                                    Reply

                                                    The Cadillac XTS looks like a big Camry. The visual elements shout "Cheap", and "Plastic".

                                                    • 1 vote
                                                    Reply#13 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 12:51 PM EST

                                                    I fully agree the new cads are ugly almost getting to the level Pontiac aztek and thats ugly

                                                    • 1 vote
                                                    #13.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 8:37 PM EST
                                                    Reply

                                                    When looks and cheap supplier prices trump quality you will NEVER fool anyone. That is just the GM way.

                                                    I've heard of lots of problems with the Cadilacks.

                                                    • 1 vote
                                                    Reply#14 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 1:03 PM EST

                                                    Cadilliac has such a stereotype attached with it, that it would be difficult to appeal to others. Personally I liked volvo until it got bough out. It looks like any other car on the inside, but with a higher price tag!

                                                      Reply#15 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 1:19 PM EST

                                                      Volvo just plain ugly

                                                      • 1 vote
                                                      #15.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 7:27 PM EST

                                                      Like I said, it depends on your demographic.

                                                      I am getting to the point where 50K is better served in my bank account.

                                                        #15.2 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 10:06 PM EST
                                                        Reply

                                                        Just give me about a 1955 Buick or similar. Steel slingshots on the freeway.

                                                          Reply#16 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 3:07 PM EST

                                                          Smooth ride, with Dynaflow transmission.

                                                          Reminds me of Broderick Crawford in Highway Patrol.

                                                            #16.1 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 7:43 PM EST
                                                            Reply

                                                            I have owned or leased over 100 cars in my life, Recently I test drove a CTSV Cadillac and I must say it was without a doubt one the most awesome cars I've ever driven [except the Maserati of course]. I'm switching back to Cadillac when my current Mercedes lease ends, GM is finally building great cars again........

                                                              Reply#17 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 5:47 PM EST

                                                              ;;

                                                                Reply#18 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 7:22 PM EST

                                                                The Cadie is super! Those saying that it is not work for other car companies. Good design and efficent.
                                                                Front Wheel drive a asset in the North in the Snow. Try a BMW in Detroit Snow

                                                                  Reply#19 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 7:24 PM EST

                                                                  FYI, BMW offers what they call x-drive which is all wheel drive so the BMW should not have a problem in Detriot snow unless the tires are not up to par or made for temps only above freezing. Perhaps the Cad has All Wheel drive as an option as well, either way stop kidding yourself we all do not work for other car companies. Most of us have been shafted as taxpayers with the GM bailout and or have owned GM products and can speak from first hand experience. German engineering has brought us some exceptionally handling autos, you just need to make sure you have a warranty or someone who is knowledgable on repairing them for less than the arm and leg a stealership will charge you. At the same time, there was a reason GM had to increase their warranty coverage from 3 to 5 years and we all know it was not from providing high quality autos in the past.

                                                                  • 1 vote
                                                                  #19.1 - Thu Nov 24, 2011 4:20 PM EST
                                                                  Reply

                                                                  In its next move, Cadillac needs to stop selling re-branded Chevy trucks...

                                                                  The finest car I've ever owned: 1967 Mercedes-Benz 300SEL (bought used).

                                                                  My primary car today: 2010 Toyota Camry SE. I can afford nearly any car, but I won't waste my money on an expensive one.

                                                                  • 1 vote
                                                                  Reply#20 - Wed Nov 23, 2011 7:35 PM EST
                                                                  Jump to discussion page: 1 2
                                                                  You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                                  As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.